Comments on: American Idol Season 7 Top 12 Girls – February 20, 2008 http://www.popsavant.com/2008/02/american-idol-season-7-top-12-girls-february-20-2008/ It's a shallow pool, and we're the lifeguards. Thu, 11 Jun 2009 10:53:52 -0400 http://wordpress.org/?v=abc hourly 1 By: admin http://www.popsavant.com/2008/02/american-idol-season-7-top-12-girls-february-20-2008/comment-page-1/#comment-15 admin Thu, 21 Feb 2008 14:44:51 +0000 http://popsavant.com/2008/02/20/american-idol-season-7-top-12-girls-february-20-2008/#comment-15 Hey neva, thanks for commenting. Interesting observation on Ryan vs. Simon, you may be right. Ryan's always shot back, but so far this season he's been the aggressor. Hey neva, thanks for commenting. Interesting observation on Ryan vs. Simon, you may be right. Ryan’s always shot back, but so far this season he’s been the aggressor.

]]> By: neva http://www.popsavant.com/2008/02/american-idol-season-7-top-12-girls-february-20-2008/comment-page-1/#comment-14 neva Thu, 21 Feb 2008 14:27:20 +0000 http://popsavant.com/2008/02/20/american-idol-season-7-top-12-girls-february-20-2008/#comment-14 I agree with you about Carly. Excellent vocal and she looked great. She's a cut above I think. Hey Im curious. Can anyone fill me in on the whole Ryan not saying Simons name and the end thing? is it just me or is the pettiness getting bit stupid. I do think that Simon was a bit more harsh with his analogies tonight and usually I agree with him. He's always spot on. But it just seems like Ryan is either scrambling for attention himself or attempting to punish Simon for doing what he does best and what everyone basically loves him for. Or loves to hate him for... whatever.... everyone wants to know what Simon thinks. No matter what Randy or Paula say, the singers all hold their breath and wait for Simons words because they know that he gets it and that he's spot on. Im in Bali so I dont see any media stuff about it but is there some little new war going on with Ryan towards Simon? It just seemed a bit rude to do it a second night in a row whether Simon smiled and took it well or not. I agree with you about Carly. Excellent vocal and she looked great. She’s a cut above I think.

Hey Im curious. Can anyone fill me in on the whole Ryan not saying Simons name and the end thing?

is it just me or is the pettiness getting bit stupid.

I do think that Simon was a bit more harsh with his analogies tonight and usually I agree with him. He’s always spot on. But it just seems like Ryan is either scrambling for attention himself or attempting to punish Simon for doing what he does best and what everyone basically loves him for. Or loves to hate him for… whatever…. everyone wants to know what Simon thinks.

No matter what Randy or Paula say, the singers all hold their breath and wait for Simons words because they know that he gets it and that he’s spot on.

Im in Bali so I dont see any media stuff about it but is there some little new war going on with Ryan towards Simon?

It just seemed a bit rude to do it a second night in a row whether Simon smiled and took it well or not.

]]>